I really loved this one at first. It lengthened, gave me the volume I wanted, didn't clump and really did wonders for my lashes. And of course I love the price (under $10 and I always have a coupon). However after a couple of weeks of use, the brush started to flake off on under my eyes when I applied the mascara. It definitely worked really well at first but then after a few weeks, I wasn't happy with the results. Definitely not my favorite Maybelline mascara.
Next up is CoverGirl's LashBlast Volume Mascara.
I'm a big fan of this mascara. It did everything I wanted and was a fantastic price (and I always have a coupon). It lengthened without clumping, gave me natural looking volume, lasted all day and never flaked off under my eyes. I've been using it for almost a month now and have no complaints. So far this is definitely my favorite mascara...I'm still going to hunt for others but this is going to be a tough one to beat.